Two pertinent questions here… and another one from me…
Are you talking a flat tow with a tow bar or towing it on a trailer?
1: Will it tow it? Yes the 2005 Jeep Liberty Limited will tow the Jeep. But hard on the tow rig.
2: Will it tow it safely? Not in my book. Getting the load stopped will be your biggest problem.
I have flat towed broken jeeps out of the hills with another jeep. (with a tow bar) They tow fine at slow speed but at highway speeds they get a little squirrelly and hard to stop.
If you are talking about pulling it on a trailer… 2500 pounds of Jeep plus 2000 pounds of car trailer make 4500 pounds total behind the Jeep Liberty with a curb weight of 4033. The good thing about a trailer is it has it’s own brakes to help you get everything stopped.
If you insist on towing it with the Jeep Liberty… Use a trailer.